Archives: Published Articles

In the second episode of the Ask the Expert video series, Susan J. Schneipp, distinguished fellow at Regulatory Compliance Associates, and Siegfried Schmitt, vice-president, Technical, at Parexel, discuss the quality requirements needed when incorporating AI in bio/pharmaceutical development and manufacturing.

 

External link to the Video Page

 

The use of artificial intelligence (AI) is seeing a surge in a variety of industries. But does the regulated nature of bio/pharmaceutical development, manufacturing, and commercialization serve up unique challenges for incorporating AI into processes? According to Siegfried Schmitt, vice-president, Technical, at Parexel, using new technology will most likely require the assistance of experts in that technology. And if you’re contracting a third party for that help, you need to do an assessment of that vendor.

 

“[T]he thing with AI, it being a computer-based technology, there is sometimes the issue of, do you have sufficient or good documentation practices applied? It’s all too easy to play around with computer code and settings and so on, but you do need to have appropriate documentation, and because you’re applying it to process development … It is something that can get inspected, so be ready for an inspection,” Schmitt cautions.

 

Susan J. Schniepp, distinguished fellow at Regulatory Compliance Associates, stresses that a robust quality management system and document control are necessary when adding AI to a process. “I also worry about if there’s the expertise to interpret what the data [are] telling you. You’re going to be collecting a lot more data than you’ve collected before, and data that’s new, and how it impacts your organization. And the data you’re collecting may prompt you to want to make a change in the coding, [but] you need to follow that stream through your quality management system,” Schniepp says.

 

Click the video above to watch Sue and Siegfried answer the question: “My company is researching the possibility of using AI in the formulation of a new product. Are there any quality considerations we should be aware of?”

 

To begin the Regulatory Compliance Associates scoping process today, please enter your information in the blue form below and click the submit button at the bottom of the webpage. You may also email us at [email protected].

Experts share insights on what the future may hold regarding biotech quality, regulatory requirements and quality standards for biotechnology industry.

 
Quality StandardThe biotech industry has experienced significant growth in recent years. These complex therapies have evolved, and with this evolution comes new challenges in ensuring the quality of these products and the safety of the patients that use them. Quality regulations, and industry, may have to continually adapt to address these challenges.
 
 
To gain perspective on what the future quality standard holds for biopharmaceuticals and how the industry and regulators will address quality going forward, BioPharm International spoke with Anthony Newcombe with PAREXEL and Susan Schniepp at Regulatory Compliance Associates (RCA).
 

Quality Standards 

 

BioPharm: With the fast development of the biopharmaceutical industry over the past 30 years, how have quality regulations adapted to address the complex nature of biologics?

 

Newcombe: Over the past 50 years, the industry has grown, especially due to advances in areas such as recombinant DNA and hybridoma technology, and more recently gene and cell therapies. As these advancements have occurred, new quality regulations have been developed to address the complex nature of biologics with specific quality requirements associated with viral safety, expression constructs, product characterization, and comparability.

 

Regulatory & Regulation

 

BioPharm: Are there regulatory guidelines in development for ensuring the quality of biologics in the future?

 

Newcombe: There is no indication that the current, published quality guidelines would not ensure the quality of biologics in the future, but it’s likely that regulatory guidance documents will continue to be revised and updated over time to adopt industry best practices and new technologies, for example the draft International Council for Harmonization (ICH) Q12 and the revised EudraLex Annex 1.

 

Biotech Consultants

 

BioPharm: Do Biotech consultants foresee science outpacing quality regulations?

 

Schniepp (RCA): I think science has already outpaced quality regulations. An example is the applicability of pharmacopeial methods for product testing. Many monographs utilize traditional high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) for testing.

 

Companies have migrated to ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC) and other sophisticated methodology, thereby rendering compendial monographs obsolete. By the time updates are made to the pharmacopeias to capture the current technological advancements, more sophisticated equipment and methodologies are being introduced.

 

The industry seems to be moving toward a continuous monitoring where results regarding product quality can be achieved in real-time. The current processes used to update procedures, systems, and filings may not be able to keep pace with the rapid introduction of technological advances. I don’t think this is new.

 

Science has always outpaced quality regulations. When dissolution testing was introduced, it took a while for that technology to be widely accepted. I think this phenomenon is more of an issue today than in the past because science innovations are occurring at a much more rapid pace and affecting all aspects of the drug product lifecycle than 20 years ago. This rapid advancement of technology makes it harder for the quality regulation to catch up.

 

Newcombe: Quality regulations ensure that biopharmaceuticals are safe and effective, and in my opinion, are generally not driven by the pace of scientific advances. However, new quality regulations are likely to be required to keep up with the development of new advanced therapies, including gene and cell therapy and tissue engineering.

 

Some of these are autologous products using a patient’s own blood components and personalized medicines can present additional manufacturing, compliance, and regulatory challenges.

 

Quality Control 

 

BioPharm: How do you see the role of the quality control (QC) unit changing versus the current quality standard?

 

Newcombe: I would not anticipate any significant changes to the role of the QC unit in the coming years. QC laboratories currently undertaking release testing for approved biologics using validated methods are unlikely to change their existing role significantly. There may also be a general reluctance to implement new analytical technologies used for testing of approved products due to potential regulatory impact with a continued reliance on established analytical methods.

 

Schniepp (RCA): I think the quality unit will evolve to be a more hands-on review of the product attributes. The quality unit will need to be equal partners with manufacturing to be able to release product quickly and solve deviations and investigations in a timelier manner than we are experiencing today. Complete investigations will still need to be performed. They will just need to be done quicker depending on the nature of the product.

 

Traditionally, the quality unit has reviewed the results of the manufacturing process after the work has been completed and the batch has been packaged. To keep pace with the new quality standard of products being developed by biopharma, the quality unit may need to be releasing product, performing investigations, and initiating changes in real time. This requires agile and flexible processes and systems that can keep pace with advancements.

 

The quality professional of the future may need to have a solid basis in science to be able to meet the demands of manufacturing. They will need to be able to quickly ascertain how a proposed change or deviation could affect the functionality and quality of a product, which will require an intimate understanding of the manufacturing and science associated with the product. To keep pace with the future, quality must be imbedded in the process and not just as the final approver for product release.

 

Biotech Manufacturing

 

BioPharm: What quality control challenges do you see developing for biopharmaceutical manufacturing

 

Schniepp (RCA): Quality control to me is the testing that is associated with determining if the product meets critical parameters throughout the manufacturing process and at release. The question is: Do we have the correct equipment, tests, and sensitivity to accurately assess the quality of products being developed today, and how will we deal with these intricacies as we advance more and more toward personalized medicines?

 

This concept should extend beyond the product testing and be assessed for the environmental support testing as well. Determining the proper tests and environmental controls as the industry moves forward will require new and novel thinking.

 

Newcombe: Recent data integrity requirements and guidelines have had an impact on data management within QC laboratories. This may present challenges for some organizations associated with the collection, processing, reviewing, and reporting of data and ensuring the accuracy and consistency of analytical results. The access and management of data stored on electronic systems within the QC laboratory is also likely to present continued challenges.

 

Article Details

 

regulatory compliance

 

BioPharm International
Vol. 31, No. 7
Pages: 16-20

 

To begin the Regulatory Compliance Associates scoping process today, please enter your information in the blue form below and click the submit button at the bottom of the webpage. You may also email us at [email protected].

 

remediation costs

Costs of Non-Compliance

An effective corrective and preventive action (CAPA) program should do more than address an FDA observation. It should identify the root cause of a nonconformance, correct the underlying issue, prevent recurrence, and provide documented evidence that the quality system has been strengthened. In this PharmTech discussion, RCA’s expert outlines key considerations for developing a detailed CAPA response that meets regulatory expectations and supports continuous improvement.

 

When responding to an FDA 483 or warning letter, companies should address each observation with a clearly documented investigation, concise root cause, containment measures, corrections, planned corrective actions, and completion dates. Ayd emphasizes the importance of timely responses, noting that responses to warning letters should generally be submitted within 15 business days. Companies should also follow up after implementation with evidence demonstrating that corrective actions have been completed and their effectiveness has been verified.

 

The article also highlights the value of objective review when FDA determines that a CAPA is incomplete or insufficient. An experienced third party can help assess whether the response addresses every cited issue and whether the proposed actions are realistic and implementable within an acceptable timeframe. Ultimately, a successful CAPA response requires thorough investigation, clear documentation, feasible commitments, and verification that the corrective actions have effectively addressed the underlying problems.

 

Read the full article: Managing the Cost of Non-Compliance

 

A well-written and well-implemented quality risk management plan is an integral element of an effective quality system. During the development of your total quality strategy, the bottom line is that things can and will go wrong. Your QA management team and QMS system need to be designed with data quality management in mind. Your team should include employees from multiple functions who understand both risk and compliance. 

 

Quality Risk Management

 

regulatory complianceThe purpose of quality risk management is to help ensure continued compliance with regulatory requirements, such as good manufacturing practices. This is critical for risks analysis when events occur during manufacturing that can impact patient safety and product quality.

 

ICH Q9

 

The International Council for Harmonization (ICH) Q9 states;

 

“Two primary principles of quality risk management are: the evaluation of the risk to quality should be based on scientific knowledge and ultimately link to the protection of the patient; and, the level of effort, formality, and documentation of the quality risk management process should be commensurate with the level of risk”.

 

In developing your company’s plan, you will need to consider key risk indicators and how to mitigate risk. Managing your company’s risk with a well-defined plan may help reduce strategic risk associated with poor ISO 9001 Standards. Most importantly, reducing inefficiencies associated with the product and the process is critical to improving quality.

 

A reduction in deviations/investigations, FDA warning letters, customer complaints, and product yield all improve the culture of quality.

 

Risk Management Framework

 

A risk management framework is used to evaluate all aspects of the manufacturing process and identify areas of vulnerability. These vulnerabilities need to be assessed for their financial risk impact on the operation and the potential level of risk they pose. Risk management in healthcare requires a holistic viewpoint from multiple departments across the enterprise. 

 

Quality Risk Management Plan

 

A well-written quality risk management plan is an ongoing process requiring risk control documentation throughout the product lifecycle. It provides a solid risk management process for how to improve efficiency and minimize operational risk. Focus your operational risk management on the important activities to improve product quality rather than low-risk activities that have little impact. These are four key elements to consider when defining your risk mitigation strategies:

 

Element One: Gap Analysis

The first element is to perform an analysis of the identified risk associated with the operations. For example, consider project risk management if your product is being produced using an older manufacturing line. There is compliance risk that an out of date manufacturing process will experience breakdowns.

 

Element Two: Risk Evaluation

The second step is to evaluate the risk in terms of its impact on your ability to supply a quality product. In this case, frequent shutdowns can lead to product rejections, yield loss, and potential drug shortages. Search for risk management solutions that anticipate these types of supply chain risk in advance. 

 

Element Three: Identify Controls

Once the risk has been identified and the impact evaluated, risk controls can help mitigate. For example, cybersecurity risk is a growing problem where manufacturing automation needs to be reviewed. Some of the possible mitigation control strategies might include conducting threat modeling to identify your risk in security. Ensure your risk mitigation plan also qualifies cyber risk management and how a cyber secure manufacturing line holistically prevents outside hacking.

 

Element Four: Data Management

The last key element needed is data input and management. Any risk management tool should be able to indicate if and when you need to employ one of your risk control strategies. Simple risk identification includes if you see an increase in downtime on the line or a steady decrease in yield. This data could be indicators that the manufacturing line is headed for a catastrophic failure and steps need to be taken to prevent a drug shortage situation.

 

Security Risk Management

 

The above discussion is only an example of a risk assessment in one area of an operation. Other areas of the process need to be evaluated for potential vulnerabilities and risk. These areas include an evaluation of the reliability of raw material suppliers, stability, and contractual supplier compliance, age and reliability of laboratory test equipment, etc. Supplier compliance also includes partnering with contract manufacturing organizations and contract test organizations.

 

Integrated Risk Management

 

A dynamic quality risk management plan will integrate the overall organization and identify high risk vulnerabilities. It will be proactive in identifying strategies for mitigation of the high-risk vulnerabilities. Data will be leveraged to perform continuous monitoring of the vulnerabilities. And, of course, the plan will provide the appropriate documentation and rationale for risk management programs.

 

Risk Management Consultant

 

Implementing a quality risk management plan in an organization can also be challenging. A risk management consultant can provide all applicable function personnel involved in the operations additional feedback. These functions include finance, manufacturing, regulatory affairs, purchasing, auditing, and senior management. The plan should be dynamic and should be modified as situations change.

 

Single-Source Vendor Risk

 

Let’s say you produce a product and you have a single-source supplier for one of your excipients. You have audited the supplier and have identified some significant gaps in their quality system. You identify this vulnerability in your quality risk management plan as a high-risk item because of the lack of vendor compliance.

 

One of your mitigation strategies might be to qualify an alternate supplier for the excipient. Once you have qualified that alternate supplier, you need to update your plan to downgrade the risk because you have taken the appropriate steps to mitigate it and eliminate the identified vulnerability.

 

Qualifying a Secondary Supplier

 

When qualifying a secondary supplier you may want to consider choosing a supplier in a different geographic location. There may be geographical situations or circumstances that could affect the ability of the original supplier to supply materials in a timely manner. This concept could also be applied not only to secondary suppliers of a raw material but also to suppliers of the final pharmaceutical product.

 

When choosing a new supplier in a different geographical location it will be important to understand the capabilities of the new region. The following Table demonstrates some of the information you will want to assess.

 

The chart identifies the Regulatory Agency in charge of the region you might be considering. It identifies the estimated number of employees currently in the industry and results of 2019 drug quality inspections (NAI, VAI, and OIA). Issues on Data Integrity are also tied to warning letter citations.

 

Geographic Risk Management

 

The decision to qualify a new location is a difficult one but with the proper information, it can be done.  Quality risk management plans are important because they help improve a company’s ability to provide a quality product to patients. They are contingency plans with identified actions that help to ensure a continuous supply of product to the market. Further, the risk management plan is designed to accelerate products that are safe, effective, and available.

 

They are dynamic documents that require integration into and data inputs from all departments in order to be successfully implemented at a company, require integration into and data inputs from all departments in order to be successfully implemented at a company.

regulatory compliance

 

 

To begin the Regulatory Compliance Associates scoping process today, please enter your information in the blue form below and click the submit button at the bottom of the webpage. You may also email us at [email protected].

Maintaining compliance to compendial requirements should be straightforward, says Susan J. Schniepp, distinguished fellow at Regulatory Compliance Associates.

 

Q: Do I need to comply with all aspects of the various pharmacopeias? (e.g., United States Pharmacopeia–National Formulary [USP–NF], European Pharmacopoeia [Ph.Eur.],Japanese Pharmacopoeia, etc.)?

 

A: This would seem like a straightforward answer, but as with most issues related to the pharmaceutical industry, it is a bit complicated. Each pharmacopeia has various sections the industry must comply with including monographs, defining the test methods and purification for excipients, APIs, and drug products. These specific monographs often refer to general test procedures (loss on drying, pH, residue on ignition) that are consistently performed respective of the materials.

 

Compendial Testing

The conditions for performing compendial testing are included in the monograph, while the details of how to perform the tests are included in the general chapter. Individual monographs will specify the use of a certified reference standard that serves as the measure to which your specific item should be compared to in determining its suitability for use. It is acceptable to use in-house reference standards as long as the company has mapped its in-house standard to the official standard. The important detail to remember is to requalify your in-house standard when the lot number of the official standard changes.

 

Not all information in the pharmacopeias needs to be complied with. The USP–NF has a section called general information chapters, which are basic guidance advice for performing various operations such as environmental monitoring. Although these chapters are not legally enforceable, users should take notes and document their process when it conflicts with pharmacopeia’s advice. Like the USP–NF, there are some sections in the Ph.Eur. that are not legally binding. These would be general method analysis of substances used in the manufacture of medicines if they are not referenced in a monogram.

 

Compendial Standards

The pharmacopeias allow for alternative methods to be used providing they are validated and the results generated from the alternative method yields comparable results to the compendium method. All the pharmacopeias have a process for updating their contents. It is up to the users of the pharmacopeias to make sure they are using the current version published by the governing authority for the specific pharmacopeia. If you follow this simple advice, you should have no trouble maintaining compliance to the compendia requirements.

 

About the article

 

 

 

Article details

BioPharm International
Vol. 36, No. 10
Page: 34

 

To begin the Regulatory Compliance Associates scoping process today, please enter your information in the blue form below and click the submit button at the bottom of the webpage. You may also email us at [email protected].

Subject matter experts from Regulatory Compliance Associates® Inc. discuss how too many organizations scramble when an FDA inspection occurs because they fail to be adequately prepared. True inspection preparedness, however, supplements internal audits with a practiced inspection process and focused behavioral training.

 

 

Internal Audit

 

While internal audits are a key component of inspection preparedness, they tend to be informal, less intense, and more focused on auditing than inspecting. True inspection preparedness supplements internal audits with a practiced inspection process and focused behavioral training for key personnel.

 

Before a FDA inspection occurs, organizations should have an inspection process in place and conduct mock inspections. Like any process, inspection readiness needs a plan that is executed, assessed, and continuously improved upon. 

 

Roles & Responsibilities 

 

The Inspection Room (Front Room) 
While inspectors often walk the facility, the inspection room provides a meeting space to review documentation and answer questions from the inspectors. In this “front room,” system owners or subject matter experts (SMEs) review and present materials to the FDA inspector. 

 

The Control Room (Back Room) 
The control room provides the documentation, interviewees, and preparation that is needed to support the inspection process. This “back room” team processes requests for information, retrieves documents from electronic systems, and also triages documents as needed. The control room is staffed with quality and technical personnel who log requests for information and alert department heads within the organization. 

Control room personnel should always:

  • Conduct a minimum of two reviews of every document prior to sending it to the inspection room:
  • Quality Review:
    • Make sure it points to valid SOPs and Work Instructions, etc.
  • Technical Review:
    • Make sure the SMEs have reviewed and are prepared to speak to the process with the inspector
  • Have back-up printers, toner, copiers and paper on hand

Some organizations appoint runners to take the data back and forth between the control room and inspection room. There are technology solutions to operationalize the inspection process as well. 

 

Behavioral Training

 

In the past, employees were often trained to give curt answers to FDA inspectors to avoid inadvertent revelations to the agency. This approach created fear and mistrust among employees, and set up adversarial relationships with FDA staff. In order to create the most beneficial inspection process environment, however, both the agency and the company need to form a partnership. Key behavioral tips for success include:

 

  • Empower the inspection and control room teams.
  • Bring SMEs into the control room to help gather data, review documents, and consult on the answer before they are summoned to the inspection room.
  • Help SMEs understand their role in the bigger picture of the inspection. Prep them on related questions that have already been asked.
  • Don’t allow an SME to bring in notes or an uncontrolled document.
  • Use the control room to debrief SMEs after meetings with the inspector.
  • Anticipate and prepare. The language used in inspector requests can provide insights. Anticipate next questions, proactively pull documents, and understand related metrics. For example, if the inspector asks about CAPA, review related documents such as open CAPAs, high-risk CAPAs, the average length of time for CAPAs, and the longest time for open CAPAs. Be prepared to answer the inspector’s next questions.

Practicing the inspection process, however, can be one of the best ways to help employees learn appropriate behaviors and response techniques. Train employees to:

 

  • Focus on the question asked; restate the question when unsure of what’s being asked.
  • Readily admit to not knowing an answer, but provide a date and time when the answer will be provided.
  • Create an environment that reinforces the positive but recognizes weaknesses, such as “we understand this is an area for improvement,” rather than “this has been a problem for a long time.”
  • Recognize the need for training across the organization on inspection readiness. Consider off-site locations as well. The FDA inspection process starts when the FDA inspector pulls up into the parking lot and interfaces with reception and security personnel. Don’t limit inspection training to just inspection and SME personnel.

 

Mock Inspections

 

Many companies conduct internal audits as part of their inspection readiness strategies. Mock inspections, however, take the next step and allow companies to actually practice the inspection room, the control room, and inspector interaction. 

 

During mock inspections, organizations set up inspection rooms and control rooms to help teams learn how to readily access documentation that would potentially be requested during an inspection. Additionally, these practice sessions give employees an opportunity to demonstrate proper behavior and interviewing techniques when working with the regulatory agency. 

 

A mock inspection can also be used to probe further on issues uncovered during internal audits. The mock Inspection team should bring in SMEs and other personnel as needed for this activity. This approach helps the organization fully understand areas needing improvement, and gives them a platform to take corrective action before the agency actually arrives.

 

Being properly prepared for inspection ensures that the inspection process will run smoother, decreases the likelihood of observations, and helps groom the organization and individuals for higher levels of future performance. 

 

Published by:

 

 

 

Medical Device and Diagnostic Industry.

 

To begin the Regulatory Compliance Associates scoping process today, please enter your information in the blue form below and click the submit button at the bottom of the webpage. You may also email us at [email protected].